There’s a general theory amongst professional mixologists and earnest cocktailians that drinks made with clear spirits (that is: vodka, gin, rum, vermouth, etc.) should be stirred with ice to chill them.The idea being that the liquor will maintain its crystal appearance and be more appealing to the eye. Some experts also claim that the cocktail tastes better when made this way. Hmmm….

It seemed to us at Mix ‘N Sip that both taste and appearance are highly subjective, and why should we be lemmings migrating towards a stirred beverage simply because someone tells us we should? After all, James Bond was singular enough to insist on a shaken libation. So we decided to put the martini to the test.

Prepping two martinis – three parts gin to one part vermouth – and with glasses at the ready, we shook and stirred and strained. Then we looked and sipped and here’s what we found.

  • Yes, the stirred drink was clear in appearance while its shaken counterpart was cloudy (bruised*).
  • Yes, there was a teensy difference in taste. The unshaken martini was ever so slightly stronger.
  • The shaken cocktail was a tad colder.
  • Just perhaps (though it may have been imagination) the stirred martini was a miniscule fraction smoother.

shaken or stirred martini But wait! There’s more to this conundrum.

Even the British Medical Journal has got in on the debate and claims that the shaken ‘tini may be healthier because of its antioxidant properties. Meaning that the act of shaking introduces oxygen into the spirits. (Frankly, if you’re concerned enough to care about that you probably shouldn’t be drinking at all). Besides, give it a minute or two and the shaken cocktail settles and then you really can’t tell any difference between the two.

Our conclusions:

  • 99 percent of the population couldn’t tell the difference between a shaken or stirred cocktail.
  • 99.99 percent of the population most likely doesn’t give a damn.
  • Do it your way! And don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.

*The term “bruising” refers to the effect that shaking has on liquor. It both aerates it and tiny shards of ice tend to break off the cubes into the alcohol.

There’s more to see on the video.


About Mixnsip

Whether you like your martini shaken, your margarita frozen, or you prefer some other elixir, is about celebrating the mixed drink.

Posted on by Mixnsip
Tagged , ,


2 Responses to The Martini: Should it be Shaken or Stirred?

  1. Bill Moon says:

    I liked your comparison, very nicely and succinctly done. I also came to the same conclusions vis-a-vis ‘shaken vs stirred’ Martinis. If you’re interested you can find my comments at http://www.shakennotstirred.US

  2. Pingback: The Vesper: it’s a can of worms (not literally) « Mountain's Malts & more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *